Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Men being made subservient to women? Whatcha think?

who's talking here?

Supervillain 1
*CU Drama Queen* 1
Major Tom 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Major Tom (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Ladies...and guys...I'd like to hear your opinions on this. I SWEAR I didn't write it but I know the guy that did. I've got my own opinion but I'd love to get your input. Society is programming men to be emotionally subservient to women Category: Romance and Relationships I think I may have found a major contributing reason that relationships fail in this country: society (at least in the US) programs men into a relationship subservience to women. The "norm" for relationships has become increasingly skewed to women's advantage in the last four decades or so. What makes me think that relationships are skewed in women's favor? Read on, I'll explain... Everyone – men and women alike – have times when their self-centeredness causes them to fall short of their responsibilities in a relationship. When men act childishly or self-centered, society doesn't hesitate to tell them to suck it up and act like an adult. When women fall short, men are expected to put their own feelings aside and accept the self-centered behavior as normal, or even to embrace it as somehow "cute". If a man should have the temerity to point out that just perhaps a woman's "feelings" are based more on imagination rather than fact, or just maybe a woman has had a hand in her own unhappiness, then he is instantly branded "insensitive". He doesn't "get it". He can't "validate" her "feelings". There are Oprahs, Dr. Phils, and relationship books by the thousands to offer support to women in their long-suffering relationships with "Peter Pan" men – men who just don't "get it". Society systematically perpetuates the notion that women need the freedom to be self-centered, petty, and immature. Furthermore, men must just accept this as some quintessential part of the female being. Men: accept, don't question and everyone will be happy. Has anyone noticed that in every movie and TV show about families (particularly sitcoms) the females are almost always portrayed as well rounded, reasonable and stable? Men are one-dimensional and usually clueless. "The Simpsons", "King of Queens", "Home Improvement" - the list is endless. The pervasive theme in family oriented movies and television over the last 30 years is that the wife/mother is sort of a benevolent dictator – level headed and wise, and always knows what's best for the family. The men tend to harebrained schemes resulting from their immaturity and "male ego". A common plot for family comedies is that the man comes up with an idea, which the woman patiently and logically explains to be an obviously bad idea. The man gets "macho" and "sticks to his guns" and does things his way. Hilarity ensues from the resulting disaster. Sound familiar? The subliminal message: men, listen to your woman. You may think you are right, but you aren't – it is just your inner Neanderthal talking. There is song after song offering men advice on how to treat women. Other than Tammy Wynette singing "Stand By Your Man" 40 years ago, how many songs are there that tell women they need to do something for men? Not many. Aretha Franklin's hit "Respect" was actually written by Wilson Picket as a plea to his wife. The record company (rightfully) figured that in the age of feminist movement a song with a man telling a women what she needed to do wouldn't sell, so they had Aretha Franklin sing it instead. Porn. I'm making no judgment here on whether porn is good or bad, but I will make the statement that romance novels are, in essence, porn for women. In porn, fantasy women practically live to selflessly please men. Men, who by virtue of their awesome sexual prowess, are SO desirable that they need not concern themselves with anything other than sex. But isn't that exactly analogous to romance novels? Men crave visual stimulation; women crave mental stimulation. In romance novels, the "hero" invariably treats the heroine like a queen. He has no needs and lives simply to fulfill hers. He's strong, handsome and knows exactly what the woman wants and when she wants it without her even having to stoop to communicate it to him. He just "gets" her. He's strong – a REAL man. He puts his feelings aside and accepts her every bit for what she is, flaws and all. Absolutely no effort required on her part. Every woman's fantasy – a man who selflessly makes her happy with no needs in return. But like porn, this is nothing more than seeking gratification without acknowledging that ANY relationship requires effort. Precisely: porn for women. If a woman complains about her husband watching porn, society pretty much tells him he should stop. It makes her feel threatened, insecure – and that's a terrible thing to do to her. She can't measure up. What do you think would happen if a man complained about his wife reading romance novels? He'd be quickly told that perhaps if he were giving her the romance she needed, she wouldn't need romance novels. He should look and act more like the Fabio-esque hero of her latest novel. Instead of whining that he can't compete, he should be bringing her flowers and spending more time at the gym. It is his fault for not measuring up. Society would never tell a woman that maybe if she looked and acted more like a porn queen, her husband wouldn't need to watch porn. Oprah will never dispense that advice. Do you see the problem here? In either case, the man is held responsible for the shortcomings in the relationship. Heads, she wins, tails he loses. If he's watching porn, HE is responsible for her feelings of inadequacy with absolutely no fault of her own. If he feels inadequate from her reading romance novels, then HE just needs to work harder to give her what she "needs" (wants). To be fair, I do not believe that most women intentionally try to emotionally subjugate men. For that matter, they may not even realize how unbalanced relationships have become since, like today's men, it is all they have ever known. It is the "norm". The sad part is that women are the ultimate losers in this system. Like any inequitable relationship, a relationship based on men's emotional subservience to women is not sustainable...  

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

To me, if you want to be emasculated by your wife, its your own fault. Im a firm believer in what you give is what you get. I cant respect a man thats constantly up my arse all the time 

Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

Why do people have to subscribe to any stereotypical role? Why can't people just do what they fucking need to do without having to constantly verify whether they are living up to society's standards? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day