Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Is this illegal?

who's talking here?

Krysti 1
~*Funky Munky*~ 3
MamaJessica2 7
SafetsGirl aka tnmomsix 2
Trailer Park Enthusiast© 3
SuckEmSillyShirley 1
JMunderscore 1
*clean* Victoria :=) 1
*CU Drama Queen* 4
Mrs. S 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

My husband started working for this company and it was 45 hours a week because it takes 9 hours a day to complete the job, it can not be completed in 8. Now this new company bought them out and they want the same work done in 40 hours. So my husband has to rush to get his work done. He operates a gigantic garbage truck, so really he should not rush or speed to get done. He can’t even take a lunch break anymore, though they still deduct it. So he is working on his unpaid break to get finished. The boss keeps complaining because no one can get done in the 40 hours. So the boss’ solution is to take away the time clock. According to him he is only paying for 40 hours of work and if no one can clock in or out he won’t have to pay overtime. However my husband has to maintain logs, including logs for DOT so there is proof of when he actually finished working. I want to know if it is illegal to take away the time clock? My husband doesn’t want to lose his job over complaining about this, so if it is illegal I was going to call it in to the Dept of labor. 

SuckEmSillyShirley --- 17 years ago -

no but you can complain about the time hes working and not getting paid for or if his boss is making him clock out for a lunch even though hes not taking one. 

Mrs. S --- 17 years ago -

If they switched the employees category from hourly to salary employees they sure can. 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

They are still hourly. 

SafetsGirl aka tnmomsix --- 17 years ago -

I can't find it but there is a law that states how many breaks /lunch time an employee gets for so many hours 

Mrs. S --- 17 years ago -

Do a search on here: http://www.osha.gov/ 

*clean* Victoria :=) --- 17 years ago -

Isn't it if they work longer than 6 hours they're required to take a lunch break otherwise the company will get fined. Thats definitely how it is at my job. 

SafetsGirl aka tnmomsix --- 17 years ago -

Isn't it if they work longer than 6 hours they're required to take a lunch break otherwise the company will get fined. Thats definitely how it is at my job. I think that's it and a 15 min break i think 8 hours is 2 15 min breaks and 1 30 min lunch 

Krysti --- 17 years ago -

Yeah it is illegal. however you look at it, as long as they are still hourly. I would definately tell him to report it asap. Gotta love those labor laws :) 

Mrs. S --- 17 years ago -

So he is working on his unpaid break to get finished. Tell him to stop doing this. Tell him to stop work at this time and take his break. Otherwise, your hubs is just as at fault for not complying and taking his lunch. It sounds like the new employer is still alloting him one your husband is just not taking it. 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

He's not taking it because he went from having 9 hours to do his job to having 8 and his employer made it VERY clear that if the work is not done in the 8 hours he will be fired. 

~*Funky Munky*~ --- 17 years ago -

yes it is illegal, they can not take away a lunch time without him getting it nor can he work that long without a lunch, he can not be expected to speed and put others lives at danger in order for them to pay out 5 less hours a week. You can go to the labor board just google that info, same place I found it, mouse isn't working right or i would copy paste. 

Trailer Park Enthusiast© --- 17 years ago -

Here's my opinion, for what it's worth: If you complain, the employer WILL find out. The company will simply say that they DID give your husband a lunch break and he CHOSE to not take it. That isn't illegal. If you use the argument "They'll fire him if he doens't get it done in 8 hours", I doubt you would get anywhere because most companies WILL fire someone if they can't keep up with the job (even if it's wrong). My best advice would be to keep quiet and deal with it if he really wants to ensure that he'll keep his job. Or he could start looking for another job if it's too hard on him. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

Yea I would have to agree with Tia on this one. All in all he's chosing to not take the break and work through it 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

Its not hard on him. But the job takes 9 hours! The previous employee knew that. Now not only are they supposed to get done in 8, but they went from 3 to 2 drivers so the route size increased and the time to do the work didn't. My husband can handle the job and does it without complaint. It is NOT possible to do it any faster with out speeding or cutting corners. When you drive around post and empty trash cans no matter what it is going to take a certain amount of time. You can't change the amount of time it takes to drive from point A to point B without changing other variables like your speed. His only issue is that if it does take longer than 8 hours they are no longer going to pay him for it after they have been for months. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

Welcome to the recession. Less workers on the same job is common now 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

My question wasn't about the break. It was is it illegal to take away a time clock or time card for hourly employees? If they are hourly, aren't they supposed to have some way of keeping track of their hours? 

Trailer Park Enthusiast© --- 17 years ago -

Its not hard on him. But the job takes 9 hours! The previous employee knew that. Now not only are they supposed to get done in 8, but they went from 3 to 2 drivers so the route size increased and the time to do the work didn't. My husband can handle the job and does it without complaint. It is NOT possible to do it any faster with out speeding or cutting corners. When you drive around post and empty trash cans no matter what it is going to take a certain amount of time. You can't change the amount of time it takes to drive from point A to point B without changing other variables like your speed. His only issue is that if it does take longer than 8 hours they are no longer going to pay him for it after they have been for months. I agree that it is a sh!tty position to be in, I was just saying that most employers don't take kindly to complaints at the labor board, lol, and if your husband wanted to keep his job, that would probably NOT be the best route to take. I'd be pissed off about it, too, but it's just one of those catch 22 situations. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. 

Trailer Park Enthusiast© --- 17 years ago -

My question wasn't about the break. It was is it illegal to take away a time clock or time card for hourly employees? If they are hourly, aren't they supposed to have some way of keeping track of their hours? I've worked hourly positions without a time clock before. It's not illegal. There is no law that says a company MUST have a physical time clock to punch in and out on. 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

Welcome to the recession. Less workers on the same job is common now The 3rd driver wrecked a truck on the first day. So they made him shop b!tch and made the other 2 pick up the slack. He is only the shop b!tch because he is the bosses Son-In-Law. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

For all you know the guys running the job have a time system that the employees don't have acces to 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

I've worked hourly positions without a time clock before. It's not illegal. There is no law that says a company MUST have a physical time clock to punch in and out on. Oh ok. It is shitty and his boss is very much a, "I can do whatever cause where else are you going to get a job" person, like he takes off to golf all day bec he knows his employees won't snitch for fear of losing their job. 

~*Funky Munky*~ --- 17 years ago -

MamaJessica2 --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment I've worked hourly positions without a time clock before. It's not illegal. There is no law that says a company MUST have a physical time clock to punch in and out on. While this is correct. It is against the law to require a 9 hour work day for an hourly employee and only be paid for 8. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

Chas her husband is chosing not to take his break 

JMunderscore --- 17 years ago -

Chas her husband is chosing not to take his break It also sounds like she's saying that if her husband has to keep working beyond 8 hours to finish the job then the employer is refusing to pay what was worked beyond the 8 hours. That in itself is illegal 

~*Funky Munky*~ --- 17 years ago -

I understand Jen that he is not taking his break because of what the boss has told him. Just from past experience what she has said, she needs to refer to the labor board. If they fire him after the report, that will go against them as well, but he WILL be without pay and without a job. I don't think anyone can really afford that right now and why his boss is using it to his advantage. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day