Group says state should do away with Pre-K
The Tennessee Center for Policy Research is calling on the state to scrap its early education program.
A recent study authorized by the legislature said while Pre-K gives children an advantage in kindergarten, the advantage disappears by the time they reach second grade.
"This program isn't working to education kids, it's not a good investment of tax dollars so it's time to stop the program and take some of the money we're spending and give it to poor and at-risk children to go to high quality Pre-K of their choice," said Drew Johnson with the Tennessee Center for Policy Research.
This makes me angry...yeah the advantage is gone by 2nd grade...but what kind of DISADVANTAGE would these kids be at if they didn't have the Pre-K program at all?
If they want to cut something, cut headstart. I have had one child in each program and my daughter that went to headstart has struggled more and thought that all you did at school was play cause thats how her headstart was.
I for one think Pre-K is a great program, My 3 year old grandson went from not talking and sign langauge to being Mr I talk 24 hours a day .LOL He has been taught so many wonderful things at Lucas Elem. Not only does Pre-K give our toddlers a head-start to school, it also gives our new moms a break for themselves, since so many are having to be the Mom and Dad now due to so many deployments, I for one love hearing the new songs he sings for me , and watch him count and seeing the diference when he plays with children and how he now shares without a total meltdown > LOL So Tennessee keep our programs for our children and thier future. Thanks Kim ( Airborne Wife # 1 )
I totally agree.. pre-k helps with socializtion skills, listening skills, learning to live separately from the parent...but not shoving them into a full day of school, it is like a little taste of this and that so as not to overwhelm them... could my/your/our kids survive without PRE-K, yes of course, but there are so many more BENEFITS to keeping it
They started last week. I think the program is not set up for what it should be set up for. They only allow a particular group of people in and it's quite unfair.
They started last week. I think the program is not set up for what it should be set up for. They only allow a particular group of people in and it's quite unfair.
What do you mean by that?
I do not know about post but if you look into the program, it is aimed at those with a lower income. It is not based on testing or who needs the curriculum more, it is based on if you are considered low-income. Quite asinine as I am sure there are children out there who deserve to be part of this program but are disqualified because they have parents who made good life decisions.
We were disqualified but my 4 year old got in pre k because daddy is deployed.So two days before school started i got a call saying they had room for my son.I love it so far it really is a great program :0)
i think that you have to live on post, and then whatever housing area you live in pertains to which school you were to attend like the other grades. I know that the Pre-K on post is a half day.
STATE - Tennessee rank 30
SMART RATING - -3.01
Kentucky was no. 31 and Arizona was the worst ... wonder if they still have pre-k
i got this info from:
http://www.morganquitno.com/edrank.htm
I live in Ky and my son got into Prep-K
and it was not based on income at all but the fact my son was three and was not talking. They never asked our income they just did a lot of testing on our son. So I don't know if you were taking about Tenn. but I know at S. Christian it was all about my son.
In most towns, cities, areas, whatever there is "headstart" or what used to be called "headstart" not sure what it is called now, but it is and was geared toward low income and or children from a dysfunctional family (aren't we all), children with learning or speech problems (do not jump on me because it is the truth.. my son was enrolled and the application included ALL of these questions regarding, health, wealth, and other personal questions determining NEED), anyway, it WAS and IS unfair to other children who just because they are NOT from lower income or they did not have any ISSUES at home then they could not attend... this is not here, but from where i was living at the time...
On post at the elementary schools it is free and M-Fr either morning or afternoon and you have to either be 4 already or 4 by Oct 1st (not sure exactly).. then there are the CDC and the YMCA Pre-k which you have to pay for and vary depending on what you want or what you have room for. The elementary school Pre-K you Must live on post or if you are in the process of moving on post you can get a letter from housing stating that you are on the waiting list and then you can enroll your child in one of the schools on post near where your house is going to be... but you have to drive them everyday until you get into your house (i know this because i did this)
I do not know about post but if you look into the program, it is aimed at those with a lower income. It is not based on testing or who needs the curriculum more, it is based on if you are considered low-income. Quite asinine as I am sure there are children out there who deserve to be part of this program but are disqualified because they have parents who made good life decisions.
So if single mother, whose husband ran out on her, child qualifies she made bad life decisions?
For our family size we could make $56,000 annually and still qualify so I don't think it fair for you to lump everyone whose child attends Pre-K into the "welfare slum" category full of POOR people who made BAD life decisions.
Also not just POOR kids, but children with learning disabilities and deployed parents can also qualify...these would be the 3 brackets where children are most likely to do poorly academically because of their situation.
I know you guys just love hearing from me....
I just wanted to add one thing.
Please do not allow a system to label your child. Just because your child does not walk, talk, read, potty train at the same rate as others does in no way make him/her slow. Children really do develop at different paces. This does not mean they are "Developmentally Challenged." What children really need is their PARENTS spending time with them. This will help them in ways a government formed system could never. Read to your children. Hug them. Praise them. Be involved with them in everything they do. Be their best friend. Stop popping the Ritalin down their throats and making them into zombies so you can have peace of mind. They need a mother, not a pill and certainly not Pre-K.
(A mother of six WONDERFULLY different children)
...Now, back to my sweet children....
Dear Angel,
I not letting someone label my child; I'm the one who stop working, to be a stay at home mom when we decide to have children. I spend every min of everyday with my son I read to him hugged, kissed spent every waking and yes sleeping moment of his life. But low and behold he got sick and stopped talking at the age of 18 months. So I decided to take him too professional who knows about speech impairments because I love my son and I want the best for him. Speech therapy cost $169.00 an hour I know. So when he turned three and could be able to get therapy for his speech problem I jumped on it. I have college degree, but what my son needed was some one who was qualified to help him where I couldnt. If my son is sick I take him to the doctor, teeth need clean dentist, needs help talking, a speech therapist. I love my son enough to know sometimes he needs more then me. I can be selfish and think I can do it all. His needs have to come first and for most. I am a loving mother of five healthy well-adjusted children. Four who are here on earth and one who really is an Angel in heaven?
ecisions?
For our family size we could make $56,000 annually and still qualify so I don't think it fair for you to lump everyone whose child attends Pre-K into the "welfare slum" category full of POOR people who made BAD life decisions.
Also not just POOR kids, but children with learning disabilities and deployed parents can also qualify...these would be the 3 brackets where children are most likely to do poorly academically because of their situation.
No, please do not misunderstand. THOSE were the words of the lady who runs the Pre-K program that 'children who comes from low income families tend to need Pre-k more' so they base it on income. NO I am not talking about a single mother. I am saying that some families chose a career, such as the Army, instead of a job and are being discriminated against because of it.
This program isn't working to education kids
What? If it wasnt for Pre K, my now K child would never have made the adjustment better and would never have talked. My son didnt talk till he was 3 and with the help of E.D.I.S. and Pre K, he learned and now talks up a storm..lol
I live right off post there are several pre-k programs at the schools that are free if you live in that school district that is not income based... however the school district i live in does not have a pre-k at there school so i had to go through head start which was income based and even being military we qualified but it is not just based on income after they rake all the income then they take other things like medical record living and deceased parents adopted children children with SSI for learning and much more it is not just wholly based on who is and who is not in there standards of low income
I am saying that some families chose a career, such as the Army, instead of a job and are being discriminated against because of it.
So the only carrer a person can have is the Army? My mom was an RN (I consider that a career) and my brother still qualified for head start. I don't get what your trying to say...if your kids got to pre-K you made bad decisions and don't have a career?
I don't get what your trying to say...if your kids got to pre-K you made bad decisions and don't have a career?
-I- did not set the standards on what LOW INCOME would be. The lady who oversees the Pre-k program said that statistics show that children from low income families tend to be less educated therefore the program is aimed at helping them versus helping those who really need it. Therefore, -I- am saying that just because you are low income doesn't mean that your child isn't as smart as someone who has a bit more $$. It should NOT be based on income but on necessity. I hope that better explains it. I am not lumping anyone in with anyone else. I just do not think its fair that there is a price range on which you are accepted into an educational free program. Just because you might make more money does not mean that you have more. It's a hard economy these days.
When I lived in lawton, pre k was part of lawton public schools and my son went. It was all day like kindergarten is but mind you they don't start pre k till they are 4. I loved pre k for him, he learned to read so much faster and got that extra time to learn the structure of school life
That's what I am saying. I think every kid NEEDS Pre-k whether they are already smart or not for the socialization and structure of it. I do not think that children should be disqualified based on the fact that their parent(s) make too much money according to the government regulations.