Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Remilitary.com!

The Army has some Nerve

who's talking here?

Krysti 3
Dianne 3
Jenn 2
Hauntedizbak 2
Rhonda P 12
Jana 2
ItsMe 1
Elizabeth G. 1
Joseph 3
Heather D. 3
#1 Klukin Hen 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

You know if a lower enlisted soldier get's in trouble for whatever reason, the unit would make it mandatory to embarrass the soldier in front of the whole unit at formation(as if he is not embarrassed enough for his action’s already ) to tell the other’s how this is not accepted in the army. If a Colonel got relieved of duty while over sea and they have now decided to bring him back home. For whatever actions he did do while over there (with all the years of experience he has to benefit over there, it must have not been good) And with that being said he doesn’t want anyone there when he comes back to the unit (because he is too embarrassed for his actions over there). (JMO) I would make it also mandatory that everyone was there no matter what your rank is (since you are representing the army). I would do this just to embarrass the same person that the entire soldier’s over the years have looked up to for leadership. I feel if you are relieved of your duties while over there you no long have the right to see what you feel is fit for you anymore. Or I would make it that everyone was to salute him and tell him what a well done job he did over there. since he really can’t do anything about it now. Does anyone feel the same way , or am i just being too mean about this ? 

#1 Klukin Hen --- 18 years ago -

ggrrr..dont even get me started on the crap they pull...they are famous for pissing on peoples legs and telling them it's raining!! 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

lol........... 

ItsMe --- 18 years ago -

Not familiar with that way of doing it but I know in my husbands unit, if they were to act up or do something wrong, they all paid the price not just the one who did it. That makes me upset. 

Joseph --- 18 years ago -

You know its the way the army does things. yeah its unfair and it sucks. had the same crap happen to me. but aint anything gonna change. it is what it is and will always be 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

With that said Joseph, Why have them stuff morales down the soldier's throats , Have them Respect for the Army , If they are not going to live up to it also. Let's throw it all out the window and draw fire troop's . 

Joseph --- 18 years ago -

so they dont get in trouble off post 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

But as we all know , every soldier's get's in fight's at bar's on Friday's and Saturday Night's. Bad checks they cant afford to pay . I feel it is the leader's have showen their soldier over the years. 

Joseph --- 18 years ago -

i blame fights in bars on alcohol but yes i very much see your point. but they give those speeches to cover there own @$$. that way when something happens they dont catch hell. i knew very few soldiers enlisted and officer that lived up to the army "standard" but its just one of those things that wont change anytime soon 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

All i got to say is do unto other's as other's do unto you . And with your statement shouldn't they practice what they preach, and have someone else give them (Colonel) that same speech to cover the main army's A$$ also . cause everything will fall back on the Higher up people also. 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

My whole point to this is dont give a speech about morale's in the Army ,if you are not going to live by the same rule. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

You have a point, but we all know that the army preaches one thing, but operates totally opposite at times. They say they are family oriented and family friendly, but I never saw any of that when my husband was in. It's all for publicity in my opinion. 

Krysti --- 18 years ago -

I know it is different unit to unit. But my hubby's unit has never publicized any member's stupid ways. If a soldier gets in trouble, it is only that soldier, and of course his chied gets yelled at for having a jacked up soldier. Also in my old unit, it was the same way, we never blabbed out everyone's business to everyone else, but we did all get punished as a group, usually just a 3 mile run or a gazillion pushups! 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

You are right, every unit does vary. My husband's old unit, they shared EVERY stupid mistake someone made. I think they got a kick out of embarassing and humilating their soldiers. And usually 8 out of 10 times, the unit or at least the platoon was punished as a whole. It was so stupid. And wives weren't treated all that better. There were a few higher ranking that even let it slip that if the army wanted their soldiers to have a wife and family they would have been issued on and that we came 2nd or last. And our military is supposed to be familiy friendly. HA HA!! I know not every unit is like this, but I know alot are. I guess it just depends on the mentality of the higher ranking in each unit as to how the unit is ran. Just pray that your husbands unit keeps good people in charge. Trust me, we dealt with alot of Sh*t when my husband was in. I even had a sgt back not long after me and my husband met, try to embarass him in front of me. 

Krysti --- 18 years ago -

Well thank god my hubby is one of those people in charge, I know it's not right for the military to say one thing and do another, but if a soldier does something illegal, then he should be used as an example for everyone else. That i believe in. Say a soldier punched his wife in the face, then by all means, it should be publicized, so everyone knows that person is a dirtbag. 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

I Agree Krysti, Things like that should be pubicized ,even if it is things as setting bad leadership to other soldier. And with that this will show to other soldiers even the highest rank are sumbags as the rest of the soldier's that get into trouble . There is no difference , as they all put there pants on the same way , one leg at a time . 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

AMEN to that. Thankfully Krysti, your husband is one in charge. My husband's old unit was all jacked up. They would try and make an "example" of a soldiers mistakes even if it was something simple and petty. Now if it's serious or illegal, by all means, make it known. But little things such as boots not shinny enough, the crease in the BDU's(remember when those were worn..lol) and DCU's at the time, not being sharp enough, or slightly uncentered, those are things that shouldn't be used to humilate a soldier over. My husband would probably have stayed in alot longer if he could have been in a differnt unit with better comanding officers and sgts. Sometimes rank goes to some of their heads. They forget that they once were on the bottom of the tottem pole. 

Krysti --- 18 years ago -

I think all that was just to look good in the public eye. I wouldn't want a soldier going out looking all chewed up with his jacket unzipped or shirt untucked... just not very professional, but I also agree, it is a little ridiculous that sometimes they go to those extremes.. some people make that E5 and it goes straight to their head, like it's so great or something. I don't think E5 is anything at all, considering there are many other people who outrank them. 

Jenn --- 18 years ago -

some people make that E5 and it goes straight to their head OMG AMEN!! One of my husband's ex best friend kissed a##..and sucked up all the dang time and some how...yea some how he got promoted to E-5 and now he thinks he is the greatest thing that has ever walked the face of the Earth. Not just it went to his head but he thinks he is always right and what you got he has something better. And oh yea did I mention he completely wrecked and destroy our 4-wheeler while my husband was in Iraq and he decides he is only paying for 20% being the atv was 2 years old! Aha I could go on and on about his guy..he gets on my nerves so much!! And...he walks on a cane at work but can run/jump up the road half drunk as crap on the weekend!! Go FIQURE 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

Ok, here is the thing. MY HUSBAND IS a E-5, soon to be E-6 (even though he does not want it, they are making it automatic now) NOT ALL E-5'S Let it go to their head. When my husband was a e-2, he had this E-5 tell him along with the rest of the soldier's that as long as he was in charge he would not let anyone get any higher then he was (YES, bad leadership) My husband NEVER let the leadership he had get to him and made a pack that he would never do this to his soldier's if he was to become one . He work hard. very hard and put up with a lot of crap from the higher ranking soldier's ( he didn’t kiss no one’s butt , and still wont to this day) My husband is a tell it like it is man . But when he made E-5. I was very proud of him, because he never gave up. The only thing my husband asks for in his soldier's is to do their job right, cause if not he is going to get yelled at, and if he gets yelled at, then they will to. My husband treats his soldier's with the up most respect, the only time my husband gets on his soldier's is when he has use less soldier's that is not willing to learn or study more about their job in order to help not only him out while over sea, but to also the other soldier's out if something was to happen (he would know what to do and not panic) .My husband has no time with use less soldiers. My husband has old soldier's (last duty station) still call him to this day. (While over seas) There were two soldiers that wanted to be the runner for my husband if he should ever need one. And as a joke my husband told them to fight it out (only playing around, no real fighting) so the one guy TEABAGGED the other and asked my husband was this good enough .lol. But when my husband got orders for here, and it was time for the same soldier to re-enlist he told re-enlistment that he would only re-enlist, if he was to get the same duty station as my husband. but they would not give it to him , so he got out . My husband has stated that soldier is loyal then a hound dog. And even though he got out, he still calls my husband to just talk about how his wife and kids are doing and how his new job is going. I do however agree that there are some low down nasty E-5's out there (I will never disagree with that) that don’t know their job to hold a leadership title. But there are other's that do and only want the best for his soldier’s. 

Jenn --- 18 years ago -

I know 98% of soldiers earn their respect and honor to their title. I was pointing to the ones who are your best friends whom act like that rank doesn't matter until they are higher. Sorry if I offended you by saying some do get where they are at by kissing butt...but I know most earn it with respect! 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

No, You didnt offend me or my husband . I was just stating that there are "SOME" good one's still out there . 

Hauntedizbak --- 18 years ago -

Only thing I can say is this: There are many civilian companies that model their leadership after the military. The group theory is very much in effect in the military....and chain of command. It's worked for a long time now, but the changes that have occured just in the last 15 or so years is BIG. Like an article 15 used to mean you are OUT of the army...period. Now it's just like a write up. Strange... 

Elizabeth G. --- 18 years ago -

As a supervisor in civ world, the only way I would bring up a persons mistake is if it was a safety issue..otherwise, I take them off to handle with noone around,, As for my hubby. he does stuff the same way, if one of his guys messes up he takes them off to the side,,but if it is something big (ie,,beating your wife up or him having to take time out of our family time to bail someone out of jail,,)..then yes,,they need to be embarrassed in front of the troop,, my hubby has been in for over 12 yrs and the army has changed so much,,I feel that they are promoting too fast,,some of these kids that are getting promoted are way too wet behind the ears to even be a leader yet.. But,, this is just my opinion.... 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

My husband was promoted fast - but he earned it and went to college to help himself in the long run. It's beyond me why most soldiers would not want to go to college! It's free and when they are deployed, they can do nearly everything online now. Plus it helps them with points and for future leadership positions and when they get out of the Army. Neither myself or my husband have been in units that NAME and SHAME soldiers in front of everyone. A lot units post article 15's for everyone to see though - more of a warning and guidance as to what will not be tolerated. 

Jana --- 18 years ago -

You know, my husbands Unit had a special name for Soldiers who thought they knew everything, "IKE" for "I know Everything". It made them keep their mouth shut a little more. Also, Mass Punishment is more of a Basic Training thing and isn't supposed to be used in the Regular Army. Sometimes you get an old school 1SG or CSM who still believes in the old ways. Think of it this way... If the Soldiers screw up here, what do you think they are gonna do overseas if they don't get punished. And most of the time, I think, that they punish the group so that the rest of the Soldiers start to look out for each other. I know it sounds stupid, but when you think it about it, it does make sense. I was in the Army myself at one time and I understand both sides, making someone stand in front of formation and telling everyone what he did wrong is embarrassing for that soldier, but it helps the other soldiers realize that if they screw up, they too will be out there. They start to look out for each other. Just my thoughts... 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

I do agree Jana, But that is my whole point to this whole thread , why is it just the lower enlisted to get punished by standing in front of the unit ? They should give the same treatment to the higher ranking soldier's that screw up ( just as much as the lower rank does )to point of being sent back home,while they were oversea . Have that high rank person out in front with a higher ranking soldier next to him ,And He should state "No matter what your rank is ,This type of behavior is not excepted in the Army". I feel if you mess up ,it should be brought to everyone's atten. You no longer have the right to think you know what is best for the army anymore. Cause if you did . You would not have been relieved of your duties. 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

What instance in particular are you talking about with a Colonel getting sent home? 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

I am unsure what it was that he did , but it had to be bad enough that he was relieved of duty. And sent home . 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

Who was it and when did it happen? I ask this for a lot of reasons. I used to work in the G3 shop (operations at the Division level). The LTC of the shop was always under constant pressure to measure up to certain political standards. The politics were not always the best course for the mission as a whole, but sometimes it was a block that needed to ticked. When a higher officer is "relieved" of his duty it is not always because he "screwed up royally". Politics amongst the senior officer ranks and even very senior Command Sergeant Majors is not uncommon. If COL X decides that he is going to do things a certain way, but GEN Y thinks things are better off another way, he may find a reason to send COL X back to the rear and replace him with COL Z - a person more to his liking. Of course not knowing what the exact circumstances are - it's hard to speculate on them. However, regardless of the incident, a Field Grade Officer should never be "name and shamed" in front of anyone. If it was a severe enough incident, then it will be a very large black mark that will follow him way into retirement. Typically Field Grade Officers go onto corporate positions, advisory positions, etc... If whatever happened is severe enough - then they can pretty much kiss there post-retirement career goodbye. They will quietly retire and seek employment out of the defense or government arena. Also finally - as a rule of thumb in the Army - senior leaders are never "called out" in front of the very people that are subordinate to them. If the offense or incident warrants an "apology" nearly every single (decent)senior leader will be willing to give it freely. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day